Top 5 Propane Water Heater Igniter Reviews

Imagine you’re camping in your RV, ready to enjoy a warm shower after a long day of outdoor activities. You turn on the water heater, but instead of the comforting sound of hot water heating up, you hear silence. The igniter has failed, leaving you with cold water and a frustrating situation. This is a common problem for RV owners and homeowners alike, and a reliable igniter is essential for ensuring consistent hot water availability.

When it comes to selecting the right igniter for your propane water heater, it’s crucial to consider compatibility, durability, and ease of installation. A great igniter should not only fit your specific model but also withstand the rigors of continuous use without frequent replacements. Furthermore, ease of installation can save you time and money, allowing you to get back to enjoying your hot water quickly.

In this roundup, we have evaluated the top five propane water heater igniters available on the market. Each product was chosen based on its compatibility, performance, and user feedback, ensuring you have the best options to consider. Let’s dive into the details of each product.

Here’s a quick comparison of the key specifications of our top picks:

Features	Lrichy 232258	SP14410 / 145-1410	SP14410 Ignitor	Dometic 92104	Lrichy 93868
Material & Build	Nickel chromium alloy	High-quality materials	ABS plastic	OEM Dometic Part	High quality materials
Key Specification	2-Prong RV Igniter	Piezo Igniter with Bracket	Piezo Ignitor Assembly	Electronic Igniter	Igniter Electrode for Atwood
Main Feature	Wide model compatibility	Battery-free operation	Easy DIY fix	Hands-free spark	Reliable replacement part
Performance	Durable for high temps	Instant gas ignition	Compact design	Restores automatic ignition	Continuous hot water supply
Best Use Case	RV owners	Homeowners	DIY enthusiasts	RV water heaters	Atwood water heater users

Lrichy 232258 2-Prong RV…

This igniter electrode is specifically designed for Suburban RV water heaters, making it an excellent choice for RV owners who need a reliable spark probe replacement. Its compatibility with various Suburban models ensures that it fits seamlessly into your existing system, allowing for hassle-free installation.

The standout feature of the Lrichy 232258 is its durability. Constructed from nickel chromium alloy, this igniter can withstand the high temperatures typical of water heater environments. This means fewer replacements and a consistent supply of hot water when you need it most. Additionally, it’s easy to install, with many users reporting that they managed the replacement without professional help.

However, some users have noted that while it is compatible with a wide range of Suburban models, it may not work with older units. It’s essential to double-check compatibility before purchasing. Also, while the two-year warranty is a strong point, some may prefer longer warranty options.

• Material: Nickel chromium alloy
• Compatibility: Various Suburban models
• Installation: Easy DIY
• Durability: High-temperature resistant
• Warranty: 2 years

Best for: RV owners needing a reliable igniter for Suburban water heaters.

SP14410 / 145-1410 Water…

The SP14410 / 145-1410 is a piezo igniter specifically designed for Rheem and Reliance gas water heaters. This igniter is a perfect choice for homeowners looking for a straightforward solution to their heating needs. Its unique design eliminates the need for external power or batteries, making it a dependable option even during power outages.

One of the most impressive aspects of this igniter is the high-voltage spark it generates with just a press of a button. This feature ensures that your gas ignites instantly, providing quick access to hot water. The installation process is user-friendly, allowing homeowners to replace the old igniter without tools or complicated steps.

On the downside, some users have reported that the igniter may not be as durable as some of its competitors. While it works well, there are concerns about its longevity under heavy use, especially in homes with high hot water demands. Also, it’s essential to ensure compatibility with your specific model.

• Type: Piezo igniter
• Compatibility: Rheem & Reliance
• Installation: No tools needed
• Power: No batteries required
• Function: Instant gas ignition

Best for: Homeowners seeking a simple, battery-free igniter for Rheem and Reliance water heaters.

SP14410 Piezo Ignitor Ass…

Similar to the previous entry, the SP14410 Piezo Ignitor Assembly is compatible with Reliance, Rheem, and several other brands like Whirlpool. This versatility makes it a strong contender for anyone needing an igniter replacement for different water heater models.

This igniter’s compact design allows for easy installation, making it a favorite among DIY enthusiasts. Users appreciate the powerful spark generated by the piezoelectric mechanism, which reliably ignites the burner for hot water on demand. The high-quality ABS material adds to its durability, providing resistance to the conditions inside a water heater compartment.

While many users have had positive experiences, some have mentioned that the compact size can make it tricky to handle during installation. Additionally, like the previous igniter, longevity could be a concern in high-demand situations.

• Material: ABS plastic
• Compatibility: Various brands
• Installation: Easy DIY
• Function: Strong spark ignition
• Durability: Good stability

Best for: DIY enthusiasts looking for a compact igniter compatible with multiple brands.

Dometic 92104 Water Heate…

The Dometic 92104 is engineered specifically for the WH-6GA, WH-6GEA, and WH-9GEA series RV water heaters. This makes it a perfect fit for those who own Dometic models and are looking for a reliable replacement igniter.

What sets this igniter apart is its OEM status, ensuring it meets factory specifications for fit and performance. This model features automatic electronic ignition, which restores the hands-free spark needed to light the burner. This feature means less hassle for users who desire a reliable supply of hot water without manual lighting.

However, installation may require a bit more expertise than some of the other options here, especially for users unfamiliar with electrical components. Additionally, while it comes with an ignition wire, users should still be cautious about compatibility with their specific unit.

• Type: OEM electronic igniter
• Compatibility: Dometic WH series
• Function: Automatic ignition
• Installation: May require expertise
• Common Fix: No-ignition complaints

Best for: Dometic RV owners needing a reliable, OEM replacement igniter.

Lrichy 93868 RV Water Hea…

This igniter is specifically designed for Atwood water heaters, making it an ideal choice for RV owners who rely on this brand. Its compatibility with a range of Atwood models ensures that it fits seamlessly into your existing system.

The Lrichy 93868 impresses with its durable construction, which can withstand continuous use in high-temperature environments. This quality reduces the frequency of necessary replacements, allowing for a reliable supply of hot water during your travels. Installation is straightforward, with many users successfully completing the process themselves.

On the flip side, users should verify compatibility with older Atwood models, as some may not be supported. Additionally, while Lrichy provides a solid two-year warranty, some customers may prefer more extended coverage for peace of mind.

• Type: Igniter electrode
• Compatibility: Atwood models
• Installation: Easy DIY
• Durability: High-temperature resistant
• Warranty: 2 years

Best for: RV owners needing a durable igniter for Atwood water heaters.

How We Chose These Products

To compile this list, we evaluated various propane water heater igniters based on several key criteria: compatibility, durability, ease of installation, and user feedback. Each product was thoroughly researched to ensure it met the needs of users across different scenarios, from RV owners to homeowners. We considered real-world performance and practical application to provide a well-rounded selection.

We also examined customer reviews and ratings to gauge overall satisfaction and reliability. Products were chosen for their unique strengths and potential limitations, ensuring our recommendations are trustworthy and comprehensive. Our goal was to highlight options for various needs and preferences within this category.

Buying Guide: What Really Matters

When selecting a propane water heater igniter, consider the compatibility with your specific water heater model. Not all igniters fit all models, so checking compatibility is crucial to avoid purchasing an unsuitable product. Look for detailed specifications from manufacturers to ensure a proper fit.

Durability is another critical factor. Igniters made from high-quality materials can withstand high temperatures and frequent use, reducing the need for replacements. Finally, consider the ease of installation. Many users prefer igniters that allow for simple, tool-free installation, saving time and potential repair costs.

Our Top Recommendation

For RV owners, the Lrichy 232258 igniter stands out as the best option due to its durability and wide compatibility with Suburban models. For those seeking a more budget-friendly solution, the SP14410 / 145-1410 piezo igniter offers an efficient, battery-free ignition method. No matter your needs, selecting the right igniter will ensure reliable hot water supply for your home or RV.

Frequently Asked Questions

What should I look for in a propane water heater igniter? Focus on compatibility with your model, durability of materials, and ease of installation.

Can I install a water heater igniter myself? Yes, many igniters are designed for easy DIY installation with no special tools required.

How do I know if my igniter is faulty? Common signs include clicking sounds without ignition or inconsistent hot water supply.

Is there a warranty on these igniters? Most products come with a warranty; check individual listings for details on coverage and duration.